Catholicism already upholds Noahide animal welfare laws and exceeds their expectations. (Code Indigo)

 See Home Page
SevenColorsMinistry@gmail.com

 This article is "Code Indigo": Animal Welfare

Catholic Upholding of the Noahide Law Against Eating Flesh from a Living Animal and Exceeding Expectations for Kindness to Animals

The Noahide Laws, derived from Jewish tradition and based on Genesis 9:3-7, are considered universal moral imperatives for all humanity. Among these seven laws is the prohibition against eating flesh cut from a living animal (ever min ha-chai), which underscores the ethical treatment of animals by forbidding cruelty in the form of consuming their flesh while they are still alive. From a Catholic perspective, this essay argues that Catholics not only uphold this Noahide law through their adherence to biblical principles and moral theology but also exceed Noahide expectations for kindness to animals through a robust theological framework, Church teachings, and practical traditions that emphasize stewardship, compassion, and respect for God’s creation.

---

Catholic Upholding of the Noahide Prohibition Against Eating Flesh from a Living Animal

1. Biblical Foundation in Genesis
   The Noahide law against eating flesh from a living animal is rooted in Genesis 9:4, where God instructs Noah and his descendants: “But you shall not eat flesh with its life, that is, its blood.” This prohibition reflects the sanctity of life, as blood is seen as the life force (Leviticus 17:11), and consuming flesh from a living animal is an act of cruelty that disregards the creature’s God-given life.
   • Catholic Adherence: The Catholic Church accepts the moral principles of the Old Testament, including Genesis, as divinely inspired. The prohibition against eating flesh with its lifeblood aligns with Catholic moral theology, which respects the sanctity of all life as part of God’s creation. The Catholic Church teaches that animals, while not equal to humans, are part of God’s good creation (Genesis 1:20-25), and their treatment must reflect their Creator’s will.
   • Practical Application: In Catholic tradition, the consumption of meat is governed by ethical considerations, including the requirement that animals be humanely killed before consumption. This aligns with the Jewish shechitah (ritual slaughter) principles that influenced the Noahide law, ensuring that animals are not subjected to cruelty by being dismembered while alive.
2. Moral Theology and the Prohibition of Cruelty
   Catholic moral theology, grounded in the natural law and divine revelation, condemns acts of cruelty toward animals as contrary to the virtue of justice and the stewardship entrusted to humanity (Genesis 1:26-28). The Noahide law against eating flesh from a living animal is inherently upheld in Catholic teaching, which prohibits unnecessary suffering to animals.
   • Catechism of the Catholic Church (CCC): The CCC (2416) states, “Animals are God’s creatures. He surrounds them with his providential care. By their mere existence they bless him and give him glory. Thus men owe them kindness.” Causing animals to suffer needlessly, such as by cutting flesh from a living animal, violates this principle of kindness and respect for creation.
   • Conclusion: Catholics uphold the Noahide prohibition by adhering to ethical standards that ensure animals are treated with dignity and killed humanely before consumption, in keeping with the spirit of Genesis 9:4.
3. Historical and Liturgical Practices
   

   Throughout Church history, Catholics have followed dietary practices that align with the Noahide prohibition. For example, medieval Catholic regulations on butchery and food preparation emphasized humane slaughter. The Church’s liturgical calendar, with its fasting and abstinence practices (e.g., abstaining from meat on Fridays in Lent), further demonstrates a disciplined approach to consumption that respects the sanctity of life, including animal life.
   • Example: The Church’s historical endorsement of kosher-like practices in certain contexts, such as avoiding blood in meat preparation, mirrors the Noahide law’s intent to prevent cruelty and honor the lifeblood of creatures.
   • Conclusion: Catholic practices, both historical and ongoing, ensure compliance with the Noahide prohibition by promoting ethical treatment of animals in food preparation.

---

How Catholics Exceed Noahide Expectations for Kindness to Animals

While the Noahide law against eating flesh from a living animal focuses on a specific act of cruelty, Catholic theology and practice go beyond this minimum requirement, promoting a broader ethic of kindness, stewardship, and compassion toward animals. This is evident in Catholic teachings, the witness of saints, and practical initiatives.

1. Theological Framework of Stewardship
   Catholic theology teaches that humanity is entrusted with dominion over creation (Genesis 1:26-28), which is not a license for exploitation but a call to responsible stewardship. Animals, as part of God’s creation, are to be treated with care and respect, reflecting their role in glorifying God.
   • Scriptural Basis: Proverbs 12:10 states, “The righteous man cares for the needs of his animal,” a principle echoed in Catholic teaching. The CCC (2418) further notes that it is “contrary to human dignity to cause animals to suffer or die needlessly.” This goes beyond the Noahide prohibition by emphasizing proactive care for animals’ well-being, not just avoiding cruelty.
   • Theological Argument: The Catholic understanding of creation as a reflection of God’s goodness (Psalm 104) elevates the treatment of animals to a moral duty. This exceeds the Noahide focus on avoiding a specific act (eating flesh from a living animal) by promoting a holistic ethic of compassion.
   • Example: The Church’s emphasis on environmental stewardship, as articulated in Pope Francis’ Laudato Si’ (2015), calls for an “integral ecology” that includes respect for animals as part of creation, urging Catholics to address modern issues like factory farming and animal cruelty.
2. The Witness of Saints and Church Tradition
   Catholic saints have long exemplified extraordinary kindness toward animals, surpassing the Noahide prohibition’s baseline. Their lives reflect a deep respect for all of God’s creatures, rooted in the belief that animals share in the goodness of creation.
   • St. Francis of Assisi: Known as the patron saint of animals, St. Francis treated animals with profound compassion, preaching to birds and taming the wolf of Gubbio. His Canticle of the Creatures praises God through all creation, including animals, reflecting a love that goes beyond merely avoiding cruelty.
   • St. Martin de Porres: This saint was known for caring for stray animals, even establishing a shelter for them, demonstrating a commitment to their welfare that exceeds the Noahide law’s requirements.
   • Conclusion: The example of these saints shows that Catholic spirituality fosters a proactive love for animals, far surpassing the Noahide prohibition’s focus on one specific act.
3. Church Teachings on Animal Welfare
   The Catholic Church has increasingly emphasized animal welfare in modern times, reflecting a commitment to kindness that exceeds the Noahide law’s scope.
   • Papal Teachings: In Laudato Si’ (para. 68-69), Pope Francis calls for a renewed relationship with creation, noting that animals are part of God’s plan and deserve respect. He critiques practices that exploit animals, such as intensive farming, which often involves cruelty beyond what the Noahide law explicitly prohibits.
   • Moral Guidelines: The CCC (2417) acknowledges that animals may be used for legitimate human purposes (e.g., food, clothing), but this must be done humanely, without causing unnecessary suffering. This principle extends to modern ethical concerns like humane slaughter, sustainable farming, and opposition to practices like animal testing for non-essential purposes.
   • Conclusion: Catholic teaching advocates for systemic changes to promote animal welfare, going beyond the Noahide prohibition to address broader issues of cruelty and exploitation.
4. Practical Initiatives in Catholic Communities
   Catholic communities worldwide engage in practical efforts to promote kindness to animals, reflecting a commitment that surpasses the Noahide law.
   • Blessing of Animals: Many Catholic parishes hold annual blessings of animals, often on the feast of St. Francis of Assisi (October 4), fostering a culture of care and respect for animals.
   • Advocacy and Education: Catholic organizations, such as those inspired by Laudato Si’, advocate for ethical treatment of animals in agriculture and oppose practices that cause suffering, such as inhumane factory farming. For example, Catholic Relief Services promotes sustainable farming practices that prioritize animal welfare.
   • Vegetarianism and Fasting: Some Catholics choose vegetarianism or veganism as an expression of compassion for animals, and the Church’s fasting traditions (e.g., abstaining from meat on Fridays) encourage a mindful approach to consumption that indirectly supports animal welfare.
   • Conclusion: These initiatives demonstrate a proactive Catholic commitment to animal kindness, far exceeding the Noahide law’s prohibition against one specific act of cruelty.
5. Eschatological Perspective
   Catholic theology envisions a renewed creation in which animals participate in God’s redemptive plan (Romans 8:19-21). This eschatological hope, seen in Isaiah 11:6-9 (where “the wolf shall dwell with the lamb”), inspires Catholics to treat animals with kindness now, as a foretaste of the harmony of the new creation.
   • Theological Argument: This vision of cosmic redemption elevates the treatment of animals beyond avoiding cruelty to fostering a relationship of peace and care, surpassing the Noahide law’s limited scope.
   • Conclusion: The Catholic hope for a restored creation motivates a proactive ethic of kindness to animals, reflecting God’s ultimate plan for all creation.

---

Conclusion

From a Catholic perspective, the Noahide law against eating flesh from a living animal is fully upheld through adherence to the biblical prohibition in Genesis 9:4, Catholic moral theology’s condemnation of cruelty, and historical practices that ensure humane treatment of animals. However, Catholics go beyond this requirement by embracing a comprehensive ethic of stewardship, compassion, and respect for animals as part of God’s creation. Through the teachings of the Church, the witness of saints like St. Francis and St. Martin de Porres, papal encyclicals like Laudato Si’, and practical initiatives in Catholic communities, the Church promotes a vision of kindness to animals that addresses modern ethical challenges and reflects an eschatological hope for creation’s redemption. In this way, Catholics not only meet but exceed Noahide expectations, demonstrating a profound commitment to treating animals with the dignity and care they deserve as God’s creatures.